23.4 Louis M. Seidman 23.4 Louis M. Seidman

Rucho is Right—But for the Wrong Reasons

Prof. Seidman, in his essay, attempts to defend the Rucho v. Common Cause decision. While acknowledging that this is not easy, he hopes that the reader will at least allow him some points for degree of difficulty. There is no denying that partisan gerrymandering is a very serious evil, and there is no defending Chief Justice Roberts’ dreadful opinion justifying the Court’s refusal to do anything about it. Still, Prof. Seidman argues, on balance, we are better off without the Supreme Court mucking around with this problem. Moreover, the reasons why we are better off go beyond this particular issue and impeach some of the standard arguments for judicial intervention more generally.

Read More